| Browse by article | Browse by volume |
Heroin Addiction and Related Clinical Problems: 2026, 28: 235-244
Icro Maremmani, Andrea Michelazzi, Michele Capano, and Lorenzo Somaini
Digital Object Identifier:
https://doi.org/10.62401/2531-4122-2026-28
Summary: The relationship between addiction and criminal responsibility remains contested, partly because legal distinctions between voluntary substance use and mental incapacity may inadequately capture the clinical heterogeneity of addictive disorders. This interdisciplinary perspective examines the implications of addiction medicine for the assessment of behavioural self-determination, integrating clinical, psychiatric and legal considerations. It distinguishes substance use, physiological dependence and addiction, and considers changes in motivational regulation associated with the disorder. A three-phase conceptual model illustrates how impaired control over substance consumption may coexist with relatively preserved instrumental planning and purposeful drug-seeking. In more severe clinical presentations, dysregulation may also affect the organisation of substance-seeking behaviour and the integration of foreseeable consequences into decision-making. The model is presented as a conceptual framework rather than a validated staging instrument. These distinctions challenge the inference that apparently intentional conduct necessarily indicates unimpaired self-determination. Michelazzi's proposed concept of capacity for culpability provides a framework for examining whether addiction-related impairment affected an individual's capacity to incorporate normative considerations into decisions relevant to a specific offence. The discussion considers limitations of the Italian legal framework concerning chronic intoxication and criminal imputability, alongside recent provisions for therapeutic alternatives to imprisonment. It also distinguishes the objectives of clinical treatment from those of penal supervision, with particular reference to relapse and opioid agonist treatment. A clinically informed assessment should neither infer diminished responsibility from an addiction diagnosis alone nor exclude impairment solely because unlawful conduct appears purposeful. Assessment should instead address the individual's functional capacities at the time of the offence, with the final determination of criminal culpability remaining a judicial responsibility.
Keywords: Addiction; Criminal Responsibility; Self-Determination; Behavioural Dysregulation; Forensic Psychiatry
| EUROPAD - European Opiate Addiction Treatment Association Brussels, Belgium, EU P. IVA 01681650469 – Codice Fiscale 94002580465 Tel/Phone: 0584 - 790073 - Email: info@heroinaddictionrelatedclinicalproblems.org |